EDHS Contemporary World Affairs

Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Woman Suspected of Witchcraft Burned Alive


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 147
Date:
Woman Suspected of Witchcraft Burned Alive


Thurs. Jan. 8, 2009
by Saeed Ahmed
cnn.com

(CNN) -- A woman in rural Papua New Guinea was bound and gagged, tied to a log and set ablaze on a pile of tires this week, possibly because villagers suspected her of being a witch, police said Thursday.

Her death adds to a growing list of men and women who have been accused of sorcery and then tortured or killed in the South Pacific island nation, where traditional beliefs hold sway in many regions.

The victims are often scapegoats for someone else's unexplained death, and bands of tribesmen collude to mete out justice to them for their supposed magical powers, police said.

"We have had difficulties in a number of previous incidents convincing people to come forward with information," said Simon Kauba, assistant commissioner of police and commander of the Highlands region, where the killing occurred.

"We are trying to persuade them to help. Somebody lost their mother or daughter or sister Tuesday morning."

Early Tuesday, a group of people dragged the woman, believed to be in her late teens to early 20s, to a dumping ground outside the city of Mount Hagen. They stripped her naked, bound her hands and legs, stuffed a cloth in her mouth, tied her to a log and set her on fire, Kauba said.

"When the people living nearby went to the dump site to investigate what caused the fire, they found a human being burning in the flames," he said. "It was ugly."

The country's Post-Courier newspaper reported Thursday that more than 50 people were killed in two Highlands provinces last year for allegedly practicing sorcery.

In a well-publicized case last year, a pregnant woman gave birth to a baby girl while struggling to free herself from a tree. Villagers had dragged the woman from her house and hung her from the tree, accusing her of sorcery after her neighbor suddenly died.

She and the baby survived, according to media reports.

The killing of witches, or sangumas, is not a new phenomenon in rural areas of the country.

Emory University anthropology professor Bruce Knauft, who lived in a village in the western province of Papua New Guinea in the early 1980s, traced family histories for 42 years and found that one in three adult deaths were homicides -- "the bulk of these being collective killings of suspected sorcerers," he wrote in his book, "From Primitive to Postcolonial in Melanesia and Anthropology."

In recent years, as AIDS has taken a toll in the nation of 6.7 million people, villagers have blamed suspected witches -- and not the virus -- for the deaths.

According to the United Nations, Papua New Guinea accounts for 90 percent of the Pacific region's HIV cases and is one of four Asia-Pacific countries with an epidemic.

"We've had a number of cases where people were killed because they were accused of spreading HIV or AIDS," Kauba said.

While there is plenty of speculation why Tuesday's victim was killed, police said they are focused more on who committed the crime.

"If it is phobias about alleged HIV/AIDS or claims of a sexual affair, we must urge the police and judiciary to throw the book at the offenders," the Post-Courier wrote in an editorial.

"There are remedies far, far better than to torture and immolate a young woman before she can be judged by a lawful system." 

http://www.cnn.com/2009/WORLD/asiapcf/01/08/png.witchcraft/index.html?iref=newssearch

Do you think there will be conflict in an effort to change this old tradition and belief?  Should witchburning be stopped, even though it's been done for many years?   



-- Edited by moniCA92870 at 18:57, 2009-01-28

__________________
monica vellanoweth v(o_o)v 
"First you take the grahm.  You put the chocolate on the grahm. Then you roast a mallow.  When the mallows' flammin', you stick it on the chocolate.  Then you top with the other side."
- Ham: Sandlot


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 71
Date:

I think this is a joke. Throughout history, haven't people realized that witchcraft is not real, and is just something that people say is true to pass blame onto other people. I understand that burning people suspected of being witches is commonplace in lesser developed areas, but it is still outrageous. People living here should look into history more and realize that there is no such thing as witches and these people should not ever be burned.

__________________


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 57
Date:

I beleive it's completely unessessary to kill someone just from asuming their status. Wheather they think their a wich or a dog i think everyone should be considered as equal. If this so called witch admitted to doing witchcraft, so be it, thats her own decision.

__________________
Four Eyes


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 248
Date:

I really thing this is a little sad. I mean I wish the world could learn from our colonies' pathetic past. Hasn't anyone read The Crucible? Its all fake! It is sad to me that people are judgemental enough to kill someone for a purpose that they have no real proof of.

__________________


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 140
Date:

this is just the product of closed-minded people. they dont want anyone to go against their grain of their "normal everyday living". whenever someone is different they are condemned. i think it is wrong that the mainstream has the say in who is right or wrong. its not really a matter of right and wrong, though, because everyone is different. but if something goes wrong, then someone deemed "strange" or "eccentric" or "different" is an easy target for blame.

-- Edited by Captain John Manassero at 18:38, 2009-01-30

__________________

I WISH I COULD BE ZOOEY DESCHANEL'S SLAVE



Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 72
Date:

this is seriously so sad. its sad that like our society could just go and kill someone without complete proof. like vanessa said, we all read the crucible last year its all FAKE. just because someone is somewhat different or out there, we jump to these ridiculous conclusion and instead of even just questioning them or anything, we just decide to kill them. its sad, and unnecessary.

__________________

beepurn :]



Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 278
Date:

Should witchburning be stopped of course. Will it, no. Its going to take a generation of no "alleged sorcery" for there to be any genuine change, but that would be difficult with parents and stuff still believing witch craft. I seriously doubt it will not stop within the next 100 years.

__________________
Go Magic! Beat La!


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 72
Date:

I think there will dlefinitely be conflict in trying to change this tradition because when people feel that their culture or traditions are being challenged, they tend to fight back, which is understandable because most or all people would. Although it is their tradition and culture to do this, it is very disturbing and dangerous. I think attempts should be made to change it for sure. But it will be very difficult. personally, i don't believe in witchcraft, but because they do it would be somewhat disrespectful to prevent them from doing this. but it is necessary.

__________________

Ayesha Hussaini <3

~ MiNoRiTy MaJoRiTy ~



Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 268
Date:

If they want to be a witch/ Warlock that's their prerogative. To say that WITCHES are responsible for a pandemic that is transmitted through intimate human contact seems preposterous. Witchburning definitely needs to be stopped...that sounds ridiculous to say.


__________________
Karen Lozano :]


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 112
Date:

Do you think there will be conflict in an effort to change this old tradition and belief? Should witchburning be stopped, even though it's been done for many years?

Yes I believe there will be conflict but I think it is necessary. But it is also important to remember of cultural differences. In our culture we hold to the view "innocent until proven guilty" but in rural Papua New Guinea it may be acceptable to burn people alive that are merely suspected of witchcraft. So although I agree the act commited against the woman was wrong I think we should keep in mind that what seems right to us may not seem right to them.  And before we intrude and impose our culture upon them we must first understand theirs.


-- Edited by lookitspeter at 19:08, 2009-01-30

__________________

"Your distress about life might mean you have been living for the wrong reason, not that you have no reason for living."  Tom O' Connor


~MiNoRiTy mAjOrItY~


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 252
Date:

There will definately be conflict because of the long tradition of "witchburning"; the people of Papua are not going to suddenly stop. However it should be stopped by all means because no matter how many voodoo dolls or incantations you chant, you're not going to murder your neighbor with evil spirits. And they are also not given a fair trial allowing them to explain themselves. The article stated that some cases of AIDS related deaths were passed off as attacks by witches. These people need to be educated so that they can make rational desicions. Maybe some of these people really did practice some sort of satanic ritial, but they should not be held responsible for the death of someone nearby.

-- Edited by Snackycakes at 19:06, 2009-01-30

__________________

Jeremy


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 127
Date:

Of course these prosecutions should be stopped. They are cleary unethical. I agree with Jason, they will most likely not be stopped. I dont think it matters in what culture you live in, the matter of the fact is that some poeple will blame someone esle for their own problems.Just like Hitler did with the Jews, people use an escape goat to blame someone for a problem or even something as little as a superstition. Witch burnings, or whatever they do to get rid of a witch is murder, but i think that most of the reason why these people get away with it is because this is so unheard of and it is probably done in private. Therefore it will be difficult to prevent.

__________________

"You never know how far you can fly until you spread your wings"

Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.



Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard